Making cheese, butter and yoghurt
Milk safety and pasteurising, hygiene, yoghurt, butter and buttermilk, fresh cheeses, hard cheese, storage, pregnancy and vulnerable people, and selling.
By Michael Johnson · Updated 19 November 2026 · How we check our guides
Turning milk into yoghurt, butter and cheese is one of the oldest ways to preserve it. Home dairy is satisfying, saves money when milk is plentiful, and is a natural partner to keeping goats or a house cow. Dairy foods are also among the most common sources of food poisoning when handled carelessly, so hygiene and temperatures matter. This guide covers milk safety and pasteurising, yoghurt, butter and buttermilk, simple fresh cheeses like paneer and ricotta, an introduction to hard cheese, storage, pregnancy and vulnerable people, and selling.
1. Milk safety and pasteurising
- Shop-bought milk is pasteurised and safe to start with.
- To pasteurise raw milk at home: heat it gently, stirring, to 63 °C and hold it there for 30 minutes, or to 72 °C for at least 15 seconds, using an accurate thermometer. Then cool quickly in cold water and refrigerate.
- UHT and long-life milk work for yoghurt and paneer but often don't set well for rennet cheeses.
- See the goats guide.
2. Hygiene
- Wash hands and sterilise equipment (pans, spoons, cloths, moulds) with boiling water or a steriliser.
- Keep pets away from the work area.
- Use a fridge thermometer: keep dairy at 5 °C or below.
- Throw away anything that smells wrong, has unexpected mould (other than intended moulds in cheese) or is slimy.
3. Yoghurt
- Heat milk to about 85 °C (just steaming, not boiling) and hold for a few minutes; this improves texture.
- Cool to about 43–45 °C.
- Stir in a spoonful of live plain yoghurt or a yoghurt starter culture.
- Keep warm (around 40–45 °C) for 6–12 hours: in a yoghurt maker, a vacuum flask, or a towel-wrapped jar in an insulated box. See the thermal cooking calculator.
- When set, refrigerate, and use within about a week. Save a spoonful to start the next batch.
If it doesn't set, smells unpleasant or grows mould, throw it away.
4. Butter and buttermilk
- Shake or whisk cool double cream until it separates into butter and buttermilk (a stand mixer or a jar both work).
- Drain the buttermilk (use it in baking), then wash the butter in cold water, kneading until the water runs clear; this helps it keep.
- Add salt if you like, shape and refrigerate.
- Salted butter keeps longer than unsalted; butter can be frozen.
- Ghee (clarified butter) keeps for longer at room temperature once all water is removed; store it sealed and clean.
5. Fresh cheeses: paneer and ricotta
- Bring milk almost to the boil, stirring, then add lemon juice or vinegar a little at a time until curds separate.
- Strain through a clean cloth; for paneer, press under a weight for an hour or so to make a firm block.
- These cheeses are made at high temperature, which makes them the simplest and safest home cheeses.
- Refrigerate and eat within a few days.
6. Hard cheese
- Hard cheeses use starter cultures and rennet to set curds, which are cut, cooked, drained, salted, pressed and then aged.
- Ageing needs a steady cool temperature (often around 10–13 °C) and humidity, and careful hygiene; a cellar or wine fridge works.
- Start with a kit or a course; follow a reliable recipe exactly.
- See the root cellar guide and the fermentation guide.
7. Storage
- Keep fresh dairy at 5 °C or below; in a power cut, see the power cut food safety guide.
- Wrap hard cheese in waxed paper so it can breathe; cut away small spots of mould on hard cheeses with a good margin, but throw away soft cheeses with mould that isn't meant to be there.
- Butter, hard cheese and ghee are the longest-keeping dairy foods.
8. Pregnancy and vulnerable people
- The NHS advises pregnant women to avoid unpasteurised milk and some cheeses, including mould-ripened soft cheeses (like brie and camembert) and soft blue cheeses, unless cooked until steaming hot.
- Pasteurised milk, yoghurt and butter, hard cheeses, and soft cheeses made from pasteurised milk (such as paneer, ricotta, cottage cheese, cream cheese and mozzarella) are safe in pregnancy according to NHS advice.
- Home-aged cheeses are harder to guarantee; vulnerable people are safer avoiding them.
- See the pregnancy guide.
9. Selling
- Anyone selling food must register as a food business with their local council at least 28 days before starting.
- Dairy products have extra hygiene and approval requirements; in England, Wales and Northern Ireland raw cows' drinking milk can only be sold directly to consumers by registered farms, at registered farmers' markets or from milk rounds, and sales of raw drinking milk and raw cream are completely banned in Scotland.
- Talk to your council's environmental health team before selling.
10. Frequently asked questions
Is homemade yoghurt safe?
Yes, made from pasteurised milk with clean equipment, set with a live culture, then refrigerated and used within about a week.
What is the easiest cheese to make at home?
Paneer or ricotta: heat milk almost to boiling, add lemon juice or vinegar, strain and press.
How do I pasteurise milk at home?
Heat to 63 °C and hold for 30 minutes, or to 72 °C for at least 15 seconds, then cool quickly and refrigerate.
11. Sources
- Food Standards Agency, raw drinking milk: food.gov.uk
- NHS, foods to avoid in pregnancy: nhs.uk
- NHS, listeriosis: nhs.uk
- GOV.UK, raw drinking milk guidance: gov.uk
New to some of the terms? See the glossary. Not sure where to start? Try start here.