Battery types compared: LiFePO4, AGM, gel and flooded
A side-by-side comparison of LiFePO4, AGM, gel and flooded lead-acid batteries: usable capacity, cycle life, weight, cost over their life, cold weather, charging and safety, and which to choose for each use.
By Michael Johnson · Updated 17 November 2026 · How we check our guides
Choosing between lithium (LiFePO4), AGM, gel and flooded lead-acid batteries is one of the biggest decisions in any van, boat or off-grid system. Lithium costs more up front but lasts far longer and gives more usable energy per kilogram; lead-acid is cheap and simple but heavy and short-lived when cycled hard. This guide compares them side by side, including cost per usable kWh over their life, cold-weather behaviour, charging and safety.
1. Side by side
| LiFePO4 (lithium) | AGM | Gel | Flooded lead-acid | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Usable capacity | 80–100% | About 50% | About 50–60% | About 50% |
| Cycle life (to 80%) | 3,000–6,000+ at 80–100% depth | 300–600 at 50% depth | 500–1,000 at 50% depth | 500–1,200 at 50% depth (deep-cycle types) |
| Weight for 100 Ah, 12 V | 11–14 kg | 27–31 kg | 30–32 kg | 25–30 kg |
| Voltage under load | Flat, about 13 V until nearly empty | Sags steadily | Sags steadily | Sags steadily |
| Charge speed | Fast: accepts up to 0.5–1C | Slow absorption phase | Slowest; sensitive to over-voltage | Slow; needs occasional equalising |
| Partial charge | Fine | Harms it (sulphation) | Harms it | Harms it |
| Charging below 0 °C | Not allowed without heating | Allowed (slower) | Allowed | Allowed |
| Maintenance | None | None | None | Top up water; ventilate (gives off hydrogen) |
| Price for 100 Ah, 12 V | Highest | Low to medium | Medium | Lowest |
2. Usable capacity: why 100 Ah isn't always 100 Ah
- Lead-acid batteries last longest if you use only about half their rated capacity each cycle. So a 100 Ah AGM gives about 50 Ah of usable energy; a 100 Ah lithium gives 80–100 Ah.
- Lead-acid also delivers less at high currents (the Peukert effect): a 100 Ah AGM might give only 70–80 Ah at a 50 A load. See the Peukert calculator.
- Lithium voltage stays flat, so equipment like inverters and fridges keeps working well right until the battery is nearly empty.
3. Cost over the battery's life
| Battery (12 V 100 Ah) | Example price | Usable per cycle | Cycles | Cost per kWh delivered |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| LiFePO4 | £300 | 1.0 kWh | 3,000 | About 10p |
| AGM | £180 | 0.6 kWh | 500 | About 60p |
| Flooded deep-cycle | £130 | 0.6 kWh | 700 | About 31p |
Prices vary: put your own into the battery cost per cycle calculator. Lead-acid can still make sense for a starter battery, a rarely used backup that sits on float, or very cold storage.
4. Cold weather
- LiFePO4 must not be charged below about 0 °C, or lithium plating damages the cells. Most BMSs block charging; self-heating batteries use some charge current to warm the cells first.
- Lithium can discharge down to about −20 °C, with reduced capacity.
- Lead-acid loses capacity in the cold (about 20% at 0 °C) but can still be charged slowly.
- Keep batteries inside the heated space where you can. See the winter solar guide.
5. Charging
- Each chemistry needs the right charge voltage profile: see the battery charging voltage calculator and the charge controller settings table.
- Lithium can draw so much current from an alternator that it overheats it: use a DC-DC charger. See the DC-DC charger size calculator.
- Switching from lead-acid to lithium usually means new charger settings and often a DC-DC charger. See the lithium upgrade guide.
6. Safety
- LiFePO4 is the most stable lithium chemistry and far less prone to thermal runaway than NMC (used in many EVs and power tools), but it still needs a BMS, correct fusing (Class T or MRBF) and protection from damage.
- Flooded lead-acid gives off hydrogen when charging: it needs a vented battery box or space.
- All batteries can deliver huge short-circuit currents: fuse close to the battery.
- See the lithium battery safety guide.
7. Which should you choose?
| Use | Best choice |
|---|---|
| Campervan or motorhome used regularly | LiFePO4, with a DC-DC charger |
| Off-grid cabin or home, daily cycling | LiFePO4 (48 V) |
| Occasional weekend use, tight budget | AGM |
| Standby backup that sits on float for years | AGM or LiFePO4 |
| Unheated storage that can't avoid freezing while charging | AGM or self-heating LiFePO4 |
| Engine starting | Starter or AGM starter battery (some LiFePO4 starter batteries exist) |
8. What about sodium-ion?
Sodium-ion batteries started appearing in home storage and power stations in 2026. They keep around 90% of their capacity at −20 °C and can usually be charged below freezing, but are a little heavier than LiFePO4, have a wider voltage range that not all inverters and chargers handle, and there are far fewer products so far. See the sodium-ion battery guide.
9. 12 V, 24 V or 48 V?
Battery chemistry is one decision; system voltage is another. Higher voltage means lower current, thinner cables and less loss. See the 12 V vs 24 V vs 48 V guide.
10. Frequently asked questions
Is lithium better than AGM?
For regular use, yes: it gives about twice the usable energy, lasts 5–10 times as many cycles and weighs about half as much. AGM is cheaper up front and can be charged in freezing weather.
What is the difference between AGM and gel batteries?
Both are sealed lead-acid. AGM holds the acid in glass mats and handles higher currents; gel uses a thickened electrolyte, lasts a little longer in deep cycling, but charges more slowly and is easily damaged by high charge voltages.
How much of a lead-acid battery can I use?
About 50% of the rated capacity for good life. Regularly going deeper shortens its life sharply.
Can I mix lithium and lead-acid batteries?
Not in the same bank. They need different charge voltages and behave differently under load. Keep them as separate banks with separate charging.
11. Sources
- Victron Energy, lithium-ion vs AGM: victronenergy.com
- Battle Born Batteries, lead-acid vs AGM vs lithium: battlebornbatteries.com
- BoatUS, the latest on lithium batteries: boatus.com
New to some of the terms? See the glossary. Not sure where to start? Try start here.